Whether date night has rolled back around or it's your first time heading out alongside a new crush, you'll want only the greatest dinner destinations. From terracotta-tinted Italians to stunning floral havens and spots with a Michelin Guide mention, these picks of the best romantic restaurants in Sheffield are gonna make you feel even more loved-up.
Last edited by Marcus Sanigar
Last updated on 23rd January 2026
Looking for a sophisticated spot to take your partner to? Then check out Cosy Club on Holly Street, where traditional and modern decor combines to create a uniquely stylish space. Cosy up on velvet sofas, surrounded by quirky paintings and golden chandeliers.
Their cocktail menu is second-to-none, and you can pair these with all sorts of delicious dishes. From double smash burgers to Thai green tofu curry or panko-crusted cod and chips, there's something for everyone here.
Treat your date to a theatrical dining experience at Guyshi Bar & BBQ, an authentic Japanese restaurant in the city centre. They've been shortlisted for both the Best New Restaurant and Best Restaurant awards, thanks to their premium dishes and welcoming atmosphere.
They offer an extensive barbecue menu, which can be prepared by you at their tableside smokeless charcoal grills. But if you prefer to leave it to the professionals, there's a whole load of sushi, wagyu, noodles and small plates to get stuck into as well.
Ecclesall Road restaurant Mowgli is a truly gorgeous spot for a date night, thanks to an abundance of pretty fairy lights and indoor trees creating a botanical vibe. As for the menu, you can expect street-food inspired Indian dishes, from paneer curry and gunpowder chicken to tea-steeped chickpeas.
The Lost & Found is a romantic date night restaurant in Sheffield that has a vintage look and a load of botanical touches to make it extra special. But that's not all, as the grill menu and quirky cocktails are sure to satisfy too.
One of the most romantic restaurants in Sheffield city centre, The Botanist has a winning formula of vintage interiors, grill dishes and gin-laced cocktails such as The Plant Pot and the Cherry Blossom Martini.
Trailing foliage and indoor trees complete the look, while their world-famous hanging kebabs are a must from the extensive menu. There are also bottomless brunches on the cards, and you'll often find live music here as well.
Romantic and Instagrammable restaurants in Sheffield are topped off by Oisoi Gathering, the flower-covered spot that boasts ceiling installations, decadent dim sum afternoon teas and an array of Asian fusion plates. It's bound to set the mood.
Make your way to No Name for a laidback restaurant in the Crookes suburb of Sheffield. This modern bistro offers a blind tasting menu on the first Saturday of every month, or swing by any day of the week for a la carte dishes like chicken liver boudin with fresh black truffle or nut-crusted confit duck.
Fancy date restaurants in Sheffield city centre don't get much better than Silversmiths, which is a dimly lit space delving out dishes made from Yorkshire's finest ingredients. Munch through crispy cod cheek, pork belly with Szechuan pickles, and fillet steak across stunning surrounds.
After date ideas for fine dining in Sheffield? Having scooped up mentions across everywhere from the Michelin Guide to The Observer, Jöro is an absolute jewel of our city's restaurants. Choose between five and eight-course seasonal tasting menus here.
A family-run restaurant on Leopold Street, Grazie's dishes are a true labour of love. Pasta is made fresh every day in its dedicated lab and paired with slow-cooked ragus, seafood specials and sensational sauces made with the family's homemade wine.
Known for its relaxed, homely atmosphere, it's the dream spot for a date night in the city. Whatever you order, you're in safe hands - head chef Giovanni Giannusa was recently crowned Best Pasta Chef in the UK at the European Pizza Show.
Securing plenty of Michelin nods, Rafters is the fine dining destination for British tasting menus. Unique interiors mix tweed with exposed brick, while food covers everything from Thai curry monkfish to beetroot and blackcurrant duck, all washed down by world wines.
Out of all the romantic Italian restaurants in Sheffield city centre, Isabellas is a candlelit favourite. There's blossom trees, chandeliers and a range of European-inspired fare to boot, meaning you won't be short on classic carbs to accompany the ambience.
The most romantic but quirky restaurants in Sheffield? Aria has got to be right up there. Found within Kommune, this oasis fronts food from the talented chefs at the hosting food hall and signature serves shaken up by expert mixologists.
To feel like you've jetted off to Sardinia while still remaining in the heart of Sheffield? Head to Kelham Island's Domo, the gorgeous terracotta-coloured Italian restaurant, bar and deli. Tuck into the region's signature dish - pecorino-filled potato dumpling - with a cheese fondue and truffle sauce twist.
