Best Italian Restaurants In Sheffield

Join ASK Italian Sheffield for lunch or dinner, where you can enjoy a delicious Italian meal in a modern, inviting setting - it even comes with its own disco ball. This centrally located gem offers a diverse menu, featuring everything from classic margherita pizzas to hearty carbonaras and tempting desserts like toffee sundaes.

Perfect for family celebrations or casual nights out with friends, ASK Italian Sheffield combines a lively atmosphere with quality service, ensuring an enjoyable dining experience for everyone.

Those of you seeking authentic plates will want to pop by Piccolino on Millennium Square, one of the best Italian restaurants in Sheffield city centre. Not only does this destination whip up mouthwatering pasta or pizza, but it's also home to an open kitchen space, terrace and cocktail bar.

If you've got a hankering for artisan pizza, then pull up a seat at this contender for the best Italian in Sheffield. Craft & Dough make its bases fresh on-site anduses high-quality ingredients to produce sensational slices. There's also mozzarella garlic bread and a rocket salad garnished with parmesan.

Cutlery Works is known among Sheffield's foodie folk for its eclectic range of vendors serving up mouthwatering grub. And lucky for us? It's also home to Little Dough. This pizza palace fires up freshly baked slices covered in tempting treats, including spicy nduja and moreish truffle oil.

Bringing a slice of Puglia to Leopold Street, Grazie serves up fresh pasta, made daily in its dedicated lab. Inspired by the owner's hometown of Polignano a Mare, the menu focuses on traditional shapes like orecchiette and cavatelli.

With head chef Giovanni Giannusa - recently crowned Best Pasta Chef in the UK at the European Pizza Show - in the kitchen, its dishes are truly show-stopping, from slow‑cooked ragùs to seafood specials.

Glamorous in every sense of the word, boasting opulent chandeliers, leather booths and velvet chairs, Isabellas is a bit of a no brainer. Head on over for beautifully prepared pasta dishes and antipasti galore across a restaurant for some of the best Italian food in Sheffield.

For an Italian restaurant in Sheffield that's all kinds of gorgeous, look no further than Domo. Settle down across the stunning terracotta space to enjoy authentic Sardinian eats, including the signature pecorino-filled potato dumplings with cheese fondue and truffle sauce.