Alley Cats Pizza

Alley Cats Pizza brings a slice of New York to the heart of Marylebone, just off Paddington Street. Inspired by the Italian-American pizzerias of Manhattan, this buzzing spot is all about bold flavours, fast service, and a laid-back vibe that keeps you coming back for more.

The menu is built around 14-inch NYC-style pizzas, with a crispy base and inventive toppings that go beyond the usual. Crowd favourites include the pepperoni with jalapeño and honey, the pulled pork and pineapple with nduja and scamorza, and the vegan ‘n’ fire with vegan nduja and crispy potatoes. There’s also a rotating special, like the mortadella folder with stracciatella and pistachio, that keeps things fresh. Don’t skip the starters either: the meatballs in basil tomato sauce are a must.

Inside, it’s all gingham tablecloths, fast-moving chefs, and episodes of The Sopranos projected on the walls. It’s got that gritty, nostalgic charm without trying too hard. The vibe is casual, the service is quick, and the portions are generous - expect to leave with leftovers in a white paper box.